Ex-CFP chair Gary Barta: Repeal NCAA’s one-time transfer exception to slow NIL-fueled player movement

Getty Images

Former College Football Playoff chair Gary Barta believes he has a solution for the quickly ballooning name, image and likeness market, which has the NCAA and its member institutions scrambling for guardrails nearly a year after its inception. Barta, Iowa’s athletic director, suggested on the “Fight for Iowa” podcast Thursday that repealing the NCAA’s one-time transfer policy would slow a feverish transfer market fueled by booster collectives disguising pay-for-play deals as NIL. 

Enacted a year ago, the policy allows undergraduates to transfer one time while maintaining immediate eligibility.

“The transfers — again, allowing a student transfer without having to sit a year — if it wasn’t for NIL, it’s a good move … a good idea,” said Barta. “Now, when you combine it with NIL, it has just become what many have called it: the ‘Wild, Wild, West.’ One idea … and I’m pursuing this and throwing it out [there] is, if we can’t totally control NIL, then let’s go back and put a one-year [sit]. If you transfer, you don’t have to lose your scholarship, but you must sit out a year. Because we can control that. And that I think [it] would slow down the NIL deals because a booster isn’t going to offer a student-athlete a big sum of money if they know they come to their university and have to sit out a year.”

Unlike others in his position, Barta called NIL “a good thing … but what has happened is it is now being used for recruiting inducements. That was never intended. It still is against the rules, but it’s blatantly being abused.”

The NCAA agrees. The Board of Directors released new guidance on Monday in an effort to dissuade boosters and collectives from promising high school prospects and potential transfers NIL deals.

It’s possible reverting back to a previous rule forcing athletes to sit out a year of competition after transferring could curtail the massive influx of portal entrants hoping to cash in on more lucrative NIL deals elsewhere. Booster collectives that have popped up to support their school’s NIL endeavors have a target squarely on their back now. 

The NCAA’s blanket year of eligibility in the wake of COVID-19 has also contributed to roster management difficulty, however, and putting the toothpaste back in the tube by restricting freedom of mobility for players just one year after they gained it could prove difficult.


We use income earning auto affiliate links. More On Sponsored Links.

Related Posts

2022-23 college football bowl schedule, scores, games, dates, TV channels, kickoff times, locations

USA Today Sports Images The full college football bowl game schedule for the upcoming 2022 season was released Thursday, and it features 43 contests spanning three weeks in December and…

Read more

Miami hires program legend Alonzo Highsmith as general manager of football operations for Mario Cristobal

Getty Images A Miami legend is coming home to “The U.” Alonzo Highsmith, a Hurricanes great from 1983-1986, is returning to the program as the general manager of football operations,…

Read more

West Virginia football recruiting: Four-star ATH Rodney Gallagher commits to Mountaineers on CBS Sports HQ

247Sports West Virginia added a massive commitment on Wednesday, as four-star athlete Rodney Gallagher committed to the Mountaineers on CBS Sports HQ. Gallagher, a junior at Laurel Highlands in Uniontown, Pennsylvania, committed…

Read more

2022 SEC on CBS schedule: Penn State at Auburn, Georgia vs. Florida highlight kickoff times, TV info

Getty Images Now that we are less than 100 days away from Week 1 of the 2022 college football season, it’s time to start finalizing the schedule with kickoff times…

Read more

College football transfer rankings: Top five teams that are better after using the portal to land new players

One year ago, Michigan State coach Mel Tucker responded to a 2-5 campaign by betting big on the transfer portal. Suddenly, the Spartans were 11-2, Peach Bowl champions and a…

Read more

Alabama recruiting: What four-star QB Eli Holstein’s commitment means for Tide’s pursuit of Arch Manning

Alabama got big recruiting news on Tuesday when Eli Holstein, a four-star prospect and the No. 54 overall player in the Class of 2023, committed to the Crimson Tide over…

Read more